P

Last First Church Denomination From To
Page Edward First, Halsey Street, Wesley Methodist 1816 1817
Pagano Carmine First Italian Baptist 1908 1917
Palin Lenox G. Walnut Street Baptist 1951/57 after 1957
Palmer A. M. Thirteenth Methodist Chapel/Belmont Mission
 		Methodist 1865/67 1868
Palmer A. M. Fairmount Chapel Methodist 1866/67 1867
Palmer A. M. Houston Street/Twelfth Chapel/Dashiell Memorial Methodist 1867 1868
Palmer R. A. St. John's Clinton Memorial A. M.E. Methodist 1890 1891
Palmer W. E. Dashiel Methodist 1891 1894
Palmer W. E. DeGroot Methodist 1901 1903
Palmer William St. John's Clinton Memorial A. M.E. Methodist 1911 1912
Papageorge Thomas St. Nicholas Greek Orthodox 1913 1916
Papageorge Thomas Hellenic Canonical Greek Orthodox 1917 1917
Pape D. H. Emanuel ( First German) Methodist 1903 1913
Pappas Nicholas St. James Greek Orthodox 1928 1937
Pardow Gregory B. St. John's Roman Catholic 1828 1832
Parker C. P. St. John's Episcopal 1913 1914
Parker Joel Park/Fifth Presbyterian September 30, 1862 August, 1868
Parlone Antonio Our Lady of Mount Carmel (Italian) Roman Catholic 1909 1909
Parsons Charles W. Eighth/St. Paul's Methodist 1888 1891
Parsons L. Fifth/Eighth Avenue/Quarry Street Methodist 1879 1882
Parsons William L. Free Presbyterian 1842 1844
Pashshovsky Theodor St. Michael's Russian Orthodox 1913 1913
Patmount Gottfried Richmond Street (Polish) Baptist 1911 1912
Patuschke Gottfried First Polish Mission Baptist 1910 1910
Paxton Wellington B. St. Philip's Episcopal 1903 1911
Pearson August S. Emmanuel (Swedish) Lutheran 1909 1910
Peel Karl J. Emmanuel (Swedish) Lutheran 1921/22 1926
Pelensky Alexius St. John the Baptist Byzantine Catholic July 28, 1907 April 1908
Peltz George A. South Baptist 1872 1876
Pennell George C. St. John's Episcopal 1879 1879
Penta Vincenzo Our Lady of Mount Carmel (Italian) Roman Catholic 1913 1913
Pentecost Hugh O. Belleville Avenue Congregational May 13, 1886 April 13, 1888
Pettit Lyman Clayton West/Bruce Street Presbyterian 1919/20 1925
Perotti Joseph St. Lucy's (Italian) Roman Catholic November 17, 1899 1932/33
Perrine Samuel A. Fifth/Fourth Baptist May, 1909 1914
Perrotta Antonio First Italian Baptist 1924 1924
Perry Calbraith B. House of Prayer/Fourth Episcopal January 10, 1888 October 2, 1888
Perry Joseph Elizabeth Avenue Baptist March  7, 1847 January 16, 1848
Pesaturo Francisco First Bethel 1894 1894
Pesaturo Francisco First Italian/Eastside Italian Presbyterian 1895 1905
Pesaturo Francisco First Italian/Eastside Italian Presbyterian 1921/22 1936
Peters George J. D. St. George's Episcopal 1908 1913
Peters Herbert H. First German Presbyterian 1915 1924
Peters Herbert H. Christ Presbyterian 1923 1924
Peters Theodore St. Anne's (German) Roman Catholic 1902 1924
Petillo Anthonio St. Philip Neri's (Italian) Roman Catholic 1909 1912
Petz Peter St. Benedict's (German) Roman Catholic 1911 1912
Peyton James V. St. James AME Methodist 1900 1900
Pfingstel James J. Christ Reformed 1953 1957
Pfost A. First German Evangelical 1889 1892
Pfraengie Hilary St. Mary's (German) Roman Catholic November 16, 1886 1909
Pfusten Thomas Emanuel ( First German) Methodist 1848 1850
Phelan H. C. St. Joseph's Roman Catholic 1889 1894
Phelps Benjamin R. St. Mark's Episcopal 1880 1882
Phillips William S. First/Clinton/Trinity Methodist Protestant 1911 1912 (Death)
Philo Solomon Congregation Oheb-Shalom Jewish 1885 1890
Piani Fiuseppe First Italian Baptist 1918 1919
Pick Bernard Second German (St. John's #2) Lutheran 1905 1917
Pickering E. Ward Mount Pleasant Baptist 1914 1916
Pierson Jr. Abraham First Presbyterian August 9, 1667 Spring, 1692
Pierson St. Abraham First Presbyterian October 1, 1667 August 9, 1678 (Death)
Pierson J. M. Roseville (Tenth) Methodist 1864 1864
Pilch Frederick First Bethel 1837 1854
Pilchik Ely Congregation B'nai Jeshurun Jewish 1947 unknown
Piles Thomas F. Cedar Grove Primitive Baptist 1930 1938
Pilz Gerard St. Mary's (German) Roman Catholic 1882 1885
Pingry J. F. Roseville Avenue Presbyterian April 27, 1854 August 30, 1860
Pitt Louis W. St. Mary Magdalene Episcopal 1919/20 1920/21
Pitt Louis W. Christ/Third Episcopal 1919/20 1920/21
Pitt Louis W. St. Mark's Episcopal 1926 1928
Plainfield Joseph F. First Italian Baptist 1919 1923
Platt P. L. First Baptist/Peddie Baptist April, 1830 April, 1831
Plowden James R. Macedonia AME Methodist 1929 1929
Poels I. P. St. John's Roman Catholic February 27, 1892 1914
Poff Hugo St. Benedict's (German) Roman Catholic 1889 1889
Polhemus Abraham North (Third) Reformed May 3, 1857 October 28, 1857 (Death)
Polhemus Isaac H. Few Smith Memorial Presbyterian 1886 July 18, 1894
Poli Aurelio Our Lady of Mount Carmel (Italian) Roman Catholic 1911 1911
Pollack M. Congregation Adath Y'Israel Mishnayes
 Jewish 1915 1916
Pollock George C. Elizabeth Ave./Lyon's Farms Presbyterian November 15, 1864 January 4, 1882
Ponder Robert Friendship (Missionary) Baptist 1924 1929
Poniatishin  Peter St. John the Baptist Byzantine Catholic November 10, 1910 May 1, 1925
Poor   D. W.  High Street/Seventh Presbyterian   November 7, 1849 1869
Poppu  F. W. Second/Franklin Street Methodist 1943 after 1943
Porter J. C. Second/Franklin Street Methodist   1835 1835
Porter John S. First, Halsey Street, Wesley Methodist 1833 1835
Porter Joseph W. Woodside/Forest Hill Presbyterian June 12, 1883 June 17, 1889
Porter Nathan First, Halsey Street, Wesley Methodist 1830 1830
Pospech Joseph St. Stephen's (Polish) RC Church Roman Catholic 1902 1902
Post Henry K. Christ Reformed 1917 1944
Potter S. B. Sixth Presbyterian 1848 1849
Potts John First, Halsey Street, Wesley Methodist 1815 1817
Powell Linda S. Trinity Reformed 1980 March 2001
Powell Sidney W. Mount Pleasant Baptist 1918 1925
Powers Henry P. Trinity/First Episcopal June 3, 1821 1830
Powers T. L. St. Antoninus' Roman Catholic 1895 1902
Prancerici Joseph St. Philip Neri's (Italian) Roman Catholic 1913 1924
Pratt G. R. East Kinney Street Baptist 1930 1930
Prentice Jr. Sartell Fifth Avenue Presbyterian March 3, 1898 April 6, 1904
Prentiss George L. Second Presbyterian December 6, 1850 April 15, 1851
Preston John J. St. Mary Magdalen's Roman Catholic 1921/22 1927
Preston John J. St. Aloysius' Roman Catholic 1915 1927
Preyer D. Charles Trinity Reformed 1886 1887
Prieth Godfried St. Peter's (German) Roman Catholic May 11, 1855 June 8, 1885 (Death)
Prince Samuel D. Roseville Chapel Presbyterian 1895 1898
Prinz Joachim Congregation B'Nai Abraham Jewish 1939 1977
Pruden John First Presbyterian August 23, 1692 June 9, 1699
Prussianos Theodore St. Nicholas Russian Orthodox 1909 1911
Puder Mechel Congregation B'nai David
 Jewish 1935 after 1941
Pugh J. H. T. Macedonia Baptist 1930 1930
Pullins James A. Zion Hill Baptist 1929 1951/57
Purcell W. A. St. Columba's Roman Catholic 1889 1889
Purcell U. A. St. James Roman Catholic 1892 1894
Putnam Daniel First Baptist/Peddie Baptist April, 1822 May, 1824
Pyndykowski Waldimir First Ruthenian Presbyterian Church/First Ukrainian of St. .Peter and St. Paul Presbyterian 1909 April 9, 1912