M

Last First Church Denomination From To
Maas C. T. St. Paul's Lutheran 1874 1876
MacAllister A. Fairmount/Fifth Baptist 1925 1928
Macauley Hugh B. Fifth Avenue Presbyterian April 10, 1890 October 28, 1896
Macaulley J. M. Christ Dutch Reformed 1872 1879
MacClaymont D. T. Third (North) Baptist June, 1890 1896
MacDaniel Frank Summerfield Methodist 1897 1900
MacDonald James H. Ninth, St. Luke's, Clinton Avenue Methodist October, 1909 1917
MacDonald W. M. Macedonia AME Methodist 1935 1935
MacFarland Everett O. Bethany Presbyterian October 9, 1891 January 4, 1903
MacGeorge Alexander Third (North) Baptist April, 1897 1900
Machinkowski John St. Stanislaus' (Polish) Roman Catholic 1888 1889
Mack John R Macedonia Baptist 1925 1925
MacKay Donald J. Emanuel Baptist 1930 1935
MacKay Donald Sage North (Third) Reformed 1896 1899
Mackie Andrew St. Paul's/Fifth Episcopal 1852 1854
Mackle C. H. St. Michael's Roman Catholic 1890 1894
MacPherson M. T. Evangel (German) Baptist 1928 1928
MacQueen Norman Fifth Avenue Presbyterian 1937 1943/51
MacRuby A. Gordon First Church Tabernacle Presbyterian 1921/22 1923
MacWhorter Alexander First Presbyterian 1759 1807
Magill George C. Grace Methodist 1919/20 1922
Magill George C. Grace Methodist 1935 1935
Makar Stephan St. John the Baptist Byzantine Catholic November 1908 August 1, 1910
Makosky Eugene C. First/Clinton/Trinity Methodist Protestant 1912 unknown
Malasics Joseph First Hungarian Presbyterian 1923 1938
Malsberry C. Broad Street Chapel Methodist 1863 1863
Mandell A.  Park/Fifth Presbyterian 1861 1862
Mann, Jr. Albert Ninth, St. Luke's, Clinton Avenue Methodist 1887 1891
Manne Roy E. Trinity/Seventh Methodist 1918 1918/1919
Manning Moses St. John's Clinton Memorial A. M.E. Methodist 1867 1867
Manrodt Henry German United Zion Lutheran 1917 1942
Manrodt Henry German United Evangelical Essex Park Lutheran 1918 1920
Manrodt Henry Evangelical Bethlehem Lutheran 1920 1922
Manzer Bernard St. Mary's (German) Roman Catholic 1875 June 17, 1882 (Death)
Marcey Sherman Parkview Presbyterian 1910 1910
Marcus Harry Congregation Anshe Sfard (Linas Hazedek) Jewish 1924 1925
Marcy Sherman H. Weequahic Presbyterian April 15, 1910 1918/19
Margulin J. Congregation Adath Y'Israel Mishnayes
 Jewish 1919/20 1920/21
Marino Valentino St. Philip Neri's (Italian) Roman Catholic 1925 1925
Mark Joseph Synagogue Anshe Warsaw Jewish 1927 1927
Mars John St. John's Clinton Memorial A. M.E. Methodist 1839 1840
Marshall James W. Roseville (Tenth) Methodist 1882 1884
Marson J. William Mount Pleasant Baptist 1936 1943/51
Martin Adam L. St. John's Clinton Memorial A. M.E. Methodist 1931/32 1932/33
Martin Daniel H. Clinton Avenue Dutch Reformed 1891 1908
Martin E. A. St. Antoninus' Roman Catholic 1907 1910
Martin L. A. Matin's Chapel Methodist 1931/32 1932/33
Martin Thomas J. St. Rose of Lima Roman Catholic 1913 1920/21
Martin Wesley Trinity/Seventh Methodist    1893 1893
Martin Wesley Fifth/Eighth Avenue/Quarry Street Methodist 1900 1903
Martindale Stephen First, Halsey Street, Wesley Methodist 1812 1813
Martindale Stephen First, Halsey Street, Wesley Methodist 1821 1821
Martyn Carlos First Reformed Dutch 1891 1894
Marvin L. C. First (Church of the Redeemer) Universalist 1837 1838
Maschman J. F. Summerfield Methodist 1910 1913
Masnicki Vitus J. St. Stanislaus' (Polish) Roman Catholic 1896 1909
Mason F. A. Third/Clinton Street Methodist 1879 1880
Mason H. G. Emanuel Baptist 1894 1895
Mason J. H. Zion AME Methodist 1895 1901
Maschop/ Marschoff John Frederick First German Presbyterian 1842 ???
Maschop/ Marschoff John Frederick First German (St. John's #1) Lutheran 1840 1855
Maschop/ Marschoff John Frederick Second German (St. John's #2) Lutheran 1840 1855
Masnicki Vitus J. St. Stanislaus' (Polish) Roman Catholic February 29, 1896 1909
Mason Edgar C. Few Smith Memorial Presbyterian May 15, 1907 February 6, 1913
Mason F. A. Third/Clinton Street Methodist 1879 1880
Mass C. T. St. Paul's Lutheran 1876 1876
Massiah J. B. St. Philip's Episcopal Unknown Unknown
Masterson William B. St. Bridget's Roman Catholic 1917 1939/40
Masur Eli Congregation Hymns and Psalms
 Jewish 1930 1932/33
Matthias B. First Bethel 1836 1837
Matthias John J. First, Halsey Street, Wesley Methodist 1831 1832
Mattson Karl E. Emmanuel (Swedish) Lutheran 1931/32 1935
Matturro James Our Lady of Mount Carmel (Italian) Roman Catholic 1914 1914
Maurus   St. Mary's (German) Roman Catholic 1897 1903
Maxwell John H. St. Columba's Roman Catholic 1916 1917
Mayberry Charles Asbury/South Market Street Methodist 1886 1887
Maybin William A. House of Prayer/Fourth Episcopal September 28, 1866 October 1, 1867
Mayer Gustavus W. St. Matthew's German Episcopal 1895 1902
Mayer P. Leonard St. Mary's (German) Roman Catholic 1871 1875
Mazour Elias Synagogue Anshe Warsaw Jewish 1929 1930/31
Mazzocca Pasquale St. Lucy's (Italian) Roman Catholic 1908 1908
Mayer P. Leonard St. Mary's (German) Roman Catholic 1871 May 18, 1875 (Death)
Mazak S. G. Zion Slovak Evangelical 1931/32 1932/33
McAlister George A. Calvary Presbyterian 1930 1943/51
McBride H. C. Centenary Methodist 1869 1869
McBride H. C. DeGroot Methodist 1880 1882
McBride William H. Asbury/South Market Street Methodist 1881 1881
McCarroll Thomas Second/Franklin Street Methodist   1837 1838
McCarroll Thomas Second/Franklin Street Methodist   1847 1848
McCarthy J. F. St. Patrick's Roman Catholic 1895 1903
McCartie Denis J. St. Michael's Roman Catholic 1892 1913
McCartie Denis J. St. Francis Xavier Roman Catholic 1912 1913
McCauley Hugh B. Fifth Avenue Presbyterian April 10, 1890 October 28, 1896
McClary J. C. St. John's Roman Catholic 1927 1929
McComb John H. Calvary Presbyterian 1927 1929
McConnel J. First United/Second Associate Presbyterian 1867 1869
McCormick Charles A. First, Halsey Street, Wesley Methodist 1895 1897
McCormick J. D. Asbury/South Market Street Methodist 1906 1907
McCormick J. M. St. Patrick's Roman Catholic 1898 1899
McCormick Joseph P. St. John's Roman Catholic 1900 1901
McCowan W. S. Trinity/Seventh Methodist    1906 1909
McCoy Berryman H. St. James Methodist 1905/06 1908
McCoy Berryman H. Eighth/St. Paul's Methodist 1925 1930
McCoy David Friendship (Missionary) Baptist 1918 1923
McCrea A. C. Centenary Methodist 1909 1909
McDaniel James D. St. Luke's AME Methodist 1933/34 1937
McDaniel W. M. Bethel AME Methodist 1918 1918
McDonald Joseph S. St. Charles Borromeo Roman Catholic 1937 after 1957
McDouall J. W. Third/North Baptist January, 1910 after 1915
McDowell John Park/Fifth Presbyterian May 18, 1905 1915
McGonegal Robert Pilgrim Baptist 1870 1871
McGregorr Patrick St. James Roman Catholic 1880 1884
McGuiness Michael J. St. James Roman Catholic 1900 1906
McHale J. M. St. James Roman Catholic 1895 1897
McHugh Francis P. St. Patrick's Roman Catholic 1919/20 1924
McIlwaine G. E. First (Church of the Redeemer) Universalist 1897 1898
McIlvaine   J. H.  High Street/Seventh Presbyterian   July 7, 1870 April 6, 1887
McKay Robert A. Fifth/Fourth Baptist 1918 1920
McKeever James I. St. James Roman Catholic 1884 1889
McKeever J. J. St. Rose of Lima Roman Catholic December 6, 1888 1920/21
McKeever Joseph B. First, Halsey Street, Wesley Methodist 1842 1842
McKown J. L. G. Roseville (Tenth) Methodist 1878 1878
McLaughlin Lalor R. St. Joseph's Roman Catholic 1914 1914
McLaughlin W. T. St. Patrick's Roman Catholic 1897 1897
McManus H. J. St. Antoninus' Roman Catholic 1897 after 1900
McManus James Sacred Heart of Vailsburg Roman Catholic October 11, 1892 November 16, 1912
McManus Michael A. St. Joseph's Roman Catholic 1878 1878
McManus Michael A. Sacred Heart Cathedral Roman Catholic 1890 1892
McManus Michael A. St. Aloysius' Roman Catholic 1892 1909
McMurdy Robert St. Barnabas/Sixth Episcopal 1868 1869
McNeely George Elizabeth Avenue Baptist January, 1909 after 1957
McNeely George Lyons Farms Mission Baptist 1914 1919
McNeely George Baptist City Temple Baptist 1925 1935
McNichol Nelson A. First, Halsey Street, Wesley Methodist 1890 1893
McNulty James St. Bridget's Roman Catholic 1940/41 1951/57
McPherson C. W. Asbury/South Market Street Methodist 1880 1880
McWhorter Alexander First Presbyterian Summer, 1759 July 20, 1807
Meacham Enoch Trinity/Seventh Methodist    1910 1911
Mead(e) A. H. Fifth/Eighth Avenue/Quarry Street Methodist 1858 1859
Mead Charles L. Centenary Methodist 1905 1908
Mead Frank S. Grace Methodist 1928 1930/31
Meagher J. R. St. Antoninus' Roman Catholic 1899 1905
Mechler Michael A. St. Peter's (German) Roman Catholic 1911 1920/21
Mechler Michael A. St. Anne's (German) Roman Catholic 1925 1939/40
Meeker J. M. Roseville (Tenth) Methodist 1889 1892
Meeker Jonathan M. Eighth/St. Paul's Methodist 1897 1897
Meier-Smith Matson Trinity/First Episcopal April 11, 1866 March 8, 1871
Meister Samuel First German Evangelical (St. John's #1) Lutheran 1919/20 1925
Mellen Henry Merle Christ Dutch Reformed 1900 1912
Mendelson Jacob Congregation Adath Y'Israel Mishnayes
 Jewish 1917 1918/19
Mendelson Jacob Congregation Tifereth Israel of Brisk Dbto
 Jewish 1919/20 1935
Mendelson Jacob Congregation Chevra B'nai Jacob Anshe Galicia
 Jewish 1925 1932/33
Mendelson Jacob Beth Hamedrish Hagodol
 Jewish 1935 after 1941
Mendl I. St. Peter's (German) Roman Catholic 1873 1873
Mercer Richard K. Walnut Street Baptist 1943/51 1951/57
Meredith Robert Eighth/St. Paul's Methodist 1867 1869
Meredith Robert R. Central/Sixth Methodist 1870 1870
Merkle Philip First German (St. John's #1) Lutheran April 13, 1834 October 2, 1835
Merkle Philip Second German (St. John's #2) Lutheran 1834 1835
Mesmer Sebastian St. Peter's (German) Roman Catholic 1885 1888
Mestice Frank P. Immaculate Conception Roman Catholic 1926 after 1957
Meyerson Jacob Synagogue Torath Emeth Jewish unknown unknown
Mezzatesta Henry St. Philip Neri's (Italian) Roman Catholic 1929 1935
Middleditch T. T. Elizabeth Avenue Baptist September, 1848 1850
Mierop Frank South Baptist 1942 1951/57
Miles Fred E. Fifth/Eighth Avenue/Quarry Street Methodist 1924 1925
Miles Fred E. Trinity/Seventh Methodist 1925 ??
Miller Alford P. Zion AME Methodist 1908 1909
Miller Everard P. St. Thomas' Episcopal October, 1896 1910
Miller J. D. Bethlehem Congregational 1910 1913
Miller John S. House of Prayer/Fourth Episcopal November 2, 1888 1918/19
Milliken R. P. Trinity Reformed 1889 1894
Millington E. J. Oldknow Fairmount/Fifth Baptist 1895 1897
Mills J. L. First/Clinton/Trinity Methodist Protestant 1887 1888
Mirkin Lipman Congregation M Iserman
 Jewish 1929 1929
Miskeld E. J. St. James Roman Catholic 1904 1906
Mitchell H. H. Bethany Baptist 1918 1918/19
Mitchell I. J. St. Aloysius' Roman Catholic 1910 1914
Moffat T. Aird First Congregational October 1, 1906 1924
Mohns Edward A. Third Presbyterian 1937 1939/40
Moloy N. St. Joseph's Roman Catholic 1875 1876
Moment John J. High Street/Seventh Presbyterian   February 17, 1911 1918/19
Monroe J. A. Third/Clinton Street Methodist 1873 1874
Monroe Samuel Y. First, Halsey Street, Wesley Methodist 1849 1850
Monroe  S. Y.  Third/Clinton Street Methodist 1852  1853 
Monteiro Anthony A. St. Paul's Presbyterian 1940 1974
Montgomery J. First, Halsey Street, Wesley Methodist 1881 1883
Montgomery Marshall F. St. Barnabas/Sixth Episcopal 1925 1936
Moodey J. Reginald St. Mary Magdalene Episcopal 1921/22 1922
Mooney F. C. Fourth/Union Street Methodist    1908 1912
Moore Austin Antioch Baptist 1939 1939
Moore   St. John's Clinton Memorial A. M.E. Methodist 1902 1903
Moore Addison Sherman Avenue Baptist June 15, 1890 1890
Moore Asher First (Church of the Redeemer) Universalist 1853 1856
Moore Daniel First, Halsey Street, Wesley Methodist 1815 1817
Moore    S. T.   Trinity/Seventh Methodist    1861 1861
Moosmuller O.  St. Mary's (German) Roman Catholic 1867 1871
Moorley J. F. St. Philip Neri's (Italian) Roman Catholic 1892 1892
Moran James St. John's Roman Catholic November, 1866 November, 1867
Moran Patrick St. John's Roman Catholic November 3, 1833 July 25, 1866
Moran Walter G. St. Antoninus' Roman Catholic 1936 1942
Morelli Felix St. Lucy's (Italian) Roman Catholic October, 1895 December 20, 1897
Morelli F. St. Philip Neri's (Italian) Roman Catholic 1895 1904
Morgan Joseph H. Bethesda Chapel/St. Luke's Mission/St. Luke's AME
 Methodist 1913 1913
Morgan William H. Central/Sixth Methodist 1897 1913
Morrell D. T. South Baptist November 2, 1853 March 12, 1854
Morrell D. T. Fifth/Fourth Baptist 1855 April 1869
Morrell Francis A. Third/Clinton Street Methodist 1844 1845
Morrell F. A. Fourth/Union Street Methodist    1854 1855
Morris John N. Trinity Reformed 1895 1906
Morris P. I. St. Aloysius' Roman Catholic 1893 1894
Morris William L. Bethlehem Baptist 1921 1926
Morris W. W. First African/Plane Street/Thirteenth Ave. Presbyterian October 1, 1871 September 1, 1874
Morrison Robert D. German United Zion Evangelical 1943/51 after 1957
Morrow J. I. Trinity/Seventh Methodist    1853 1854
Morrow John I. Houston Street/Twelfth Chapel/Dashiell Memorial Methodist 1887 1888
Morse B. C. Elizabeth Avenue Baptist March, 1839 1841
Morse Levi Third/North Baptist 1854 1856
Morrill D. T. South Baptist 1853 March 12, 1854
Morrill D. T. Fifth  Baptist 1855 April, 1869
Morse L.  Third/North Baptist 1856 1859
Mortenson V. A. M. Danish Lutheran 1915 1917
Moses Riley Macedonia AME Methodist 1930/31 1930/31
Mossburger Luke St. Benedict's (German) Roman Catholic 1917 1920/21
Moulsdale Gilbert DeGroot Methodist 1924 1925
Mueller John Emanuel ( First German) Methodist 1913 1926
Mueller L. C. Montgomery Street Methodist 1893 1896
Muller L. C. DeGroot Methodist 1913 1918/19
Muller Ruppert St. Augustine's (German) Roman Catholic 1886 1890
Muller R. St. Antoninus' Roman Catholic 1889 1889
Mulhall J. J. St. Joseph's Roman Catholic 1895 1901
Mulhall J. J. St. Mary Magdalen's Roman Catholic 1906 1911
Murkland Harry Y. Central/Sixth Methodist 1913 1920/21
Murnyn Andrew G. St. Michael's Russian Orthodox 1912 1912
Murphy I. D. St. John's Roman Catholic 1882 1883
Murray J. J. First/Clinton/Trinity Methodist Protestant 1860 1863
Murray J. T. First/Clinton/Trinity Methodist Protestant 1874 1876
Murphy J. J. St. James Roman Catholic 1885 1886
Murphy John J. St. James Roman Catholic 1921/22 1930/31
Murphy John J. Sacred Heart of Vailsburg Roman Catholic 1932 1952
Mytton L. V. C. North Park/House of Hope Presbyterian 1909 1909